Contact   Imprint   Advertising   Guidelines

How to Try to Avoid Negative Shark Encounters

Lots of valuable articles from Rick Iossi, FKA Inc.
User avatar
RickI
Very Frequent Poster
Posts: 9117
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2002 1:00 am
Local Beach: SE Florida
Gear: Cabrinha
Brand Affiliation: Cabrinha
Location: Florida
Has thanked: 88 times
Been thanked: 101 times

How to Try to Avoid Negative Shark Encounters

Postby RickI » Mon Apr 23, 2007 4:17 pm

This was first written back in 2002, ideas for consideration have been added over the years. I have heard of about sixteen attacks on kiteboarders since 2000 worldwide up to 2015 including one fatal attack in March 2010 in Florida and a second fatal attack involving a 15 year old in New Caledonia in 2011. The frequency of such reported attacks appears to be quite low. We are still learning about shark attacks and interactions with kiteboarders. As such there are few absolutes of means of avoiding problems. Approaches recommended for other activities have been adopted with some additions in consideration of our sport.

A widely accepted list of precautions appears at: http://www.flmnh.ufl.edu/fish/sharks/At ... reduce.htm

The rules that I generally tried to follow to reduce the odds of negative shark interactions over a very long time of diving follow with some additions. They have been adapted to kiteboarding and may or may not help avoid problems with sharks.

1. Avoid making periodic noise or splashing. Dying or struggling fish emit a characteristic acoustic signature that has been documented to attract sharks for a very long time. It is interesting that a poorly performed (lots of splashing); Australian crawl stroke emulates this signature. So that flashy, splashy stroke that serves so well in the pool can be a dinner bell in the ocean. In the ocean keep your swimming cool, quiet and smooth.

Of course kiteboards toss an incredible amount of spray and no doubt generate tremendous noise underwater. For what ever reason, aside from inducing occasional curiosity, kiteboarding in my experience to date anyway, doesn't seem to unduly attract sharks in MY AREA. They may show some interest or not based on kite video clips I have seen. I am really not sure why the noise and spray of kiteboarding doesn't attract sharks either. This may not apply in other areas.

2. Avoid schools of bait fish, seasonal migrations of bait fish and particularly bait fish that are disturbed/being fed upon. That is baits that are periodically flying out of the water because something larger and hungry is chasing them. Birds may often be diving into the school being fed upon as well. I ignored this one of the times I was intercepted and checked out by an 8 ft. curious shark. Whoops! This extends to other signs of feeding, clusters of sea birds on over over the water, disturbed surface, predatory fish jumping out of the water, weed lines, dead fish or animals in the water and other signs of related activity.

Avoid congregations of sharks including migrations. Sharks may often be solitary but at times they gather into a common area for mating, birthing and related migrations. Migrations may be attended by larger, often more aggressive sharks like tigers, bulls and hammerheads in small but significant numbers. Also, video from kites and reported observations from low flying aircraft indicate that sharks may turn with kiters and chase them. Attacks rarely happen but all the same, playing cat and mouse with sharks, likely without your immediate knowledge doesn't sound like a great idea. Our first kiteboarder fatality occurred during a shark migration in Florida in March 2010. He may have been struck by a larger, predatory shark escorting the smaller spinner sharks in the migration. His femoral artery was severed in the hit and run attack. There have been at least four other kiteboarders bitten during the seasonal spinner/blacktip shark migration that I have heard about.

3. Don't go near fishing piers or down current of fishing boats and particularly fishermen that are chumming (tossing fish parts into the water). Inlets can have elevated populations of sharks as well. The fish fluids can be sensed by sharks over great distance due to the electro-chemical reaction with seawater and the highly sensitive sensory receptors along the side of the shark's body. They tend to follow these sensory trails upstream to their origin. One of Paul Menta's more notable shark encounters was close to a fishing pier in an area frequented by sharks in NW Florida many years ago. So he was in the neighborhood, splashing and his board leash looked tasty so lets have a bite on it?! Another reason not to use board leashes! Avoiding riding near inlets may also help to reduce the chances of a shark encounter.

4. Unless you want to see sharks, underwater preferably, don't go out where sharks have recently been seen, that day? Sharks are generally elusive creatures in the more populous areas of SE Florida. It is rare to encounter a shark on the surface or see one inside the limits of visibility underwater outside of the shark migrations. I generally assume that sharks are always within sensory range, say under 1/4 mi. or closer but they generally remain invisible. If you talk to airplane pilots in the area they will back this up with frequent sightings of sharks near bathers while flying overhead. In order to see sharks they generally need to change their behavior. So if that sharks are in a public mood, chasing baits or trolling on the surface it would be good to go somewhere else. Jumping sharks frequent the area of two other kiteboarder attacks on the east coast of Florida. Spinner sharks have major annual migrations along the southeast Atlantic and Gulf coasts. They were named for their tendency to jump and spin out of the water to help them kill fish which are also migrating. The Spinner and very similar blacktip sharks are known to migrate to the south in the fall, perhaps to congregate in Broward and Miami-Dade Counties on the SE Coast. In the spring they migrate north to the Carolinas to give birth. Spinner/blacktip sharks don't seem to like the way people taste and may make "bite and run" attacks. Even one bite can cause serious problems depending on the location and severity however.

5. Avoid wearing jewelry (i.e. lures) and bright contrasting colors. Apparently the bright contrasting colors can aid the sharks poor eyesight. I have heard about the "don't look like a seal" argument for almost 40 yrs. We don't have seals in my area not to say the sharks don't have racial memory of it so I am on the fence on this one. The jewelry thing is an absolute in my book and particularly to avoid barracuda attacks. Barracudas are as common as mosquitoes in my area and can hit anything small that moves and catches their eye. When I was a little kid I used to throw seashells to drop in front of the to watch them strike the shells.

The eyesight of sharks is weak and surpassed by several other far more effective senses in sharks. Interestingly enough they cover their eyes with a membrane just before attacking further impairing this questionable sense in turbid, often dark water.

6. Prime feeding time appears to be around sunset and sunrise. Shark attack on humans may be not directly related to feeding however. Sharks prefer fish, apparently are not fond of the taste of humans. Still, they may strike if startled, say if you wipe out near them, in defense of territory, etc.. If sharks are in a feeding behavior or mode, sudden stimulation caused by a kiter in the water or wiping out may prompt an attack.

7. In the case of kiteboarding, I would advise avoid staying in the water for extended periods if this is possible. A rider underway can easily be hit as has happened in a few cases but I suspect that a stationary target that has drawn the interest of a shark may be more vulnerable. Surfers and bathers experience apparently more frequent shark attacks. When you are in the water you may adopt some of those characteristics. Falling near sharks has likely resulted in attacks more than once on kiteboarders. Kiting alone may increase the odds of attack as well as potentially impair the speed of rescue if needed.

8. Lastly if a shark comes up on you and you are underway, I would advise leaving the area on your board at best possible speed. I would land and think over continuing to ride that day. If you are in the water and a shark comes up, try to water start and get out of Dodge if you can. If you can't move away, something other kiteboarders have successfully done is to respond with aggression against the shark. Some shark psychologists feel that aggression is outside of the experience and racial memory of most sharks and they often decide to go to easier pastures. I don't believe in shark psychologists but it sounds worth trying to me in any case. If the shark appears to leave the area, body drag, swim or water start and leave the area at best possible speed. If you are in the water don't splash and keep looking around you to verify that the shark doesn't come back.

So in summary, sharks, are they out there? Yes. Do they generally make a serious problem of themselves or even become visible, no. If they are visible or known to be close by your risk of a negative encounter increase. Follow good common sense procedures, some are tossed out above and have fun. I would not dwell on the subject of sharks but be ready to try to deal with the situation if it arises. Anytime you are in the water you could have a negative encounter with a shark but fortunately they are quite rare. The above comments are derived from a long time diving in Florida and the Caribbean. Florida leads the world by far in shark attacks, generally on bathers. We don't hold a candle though to the more serious incidents that occur in South Africa, Australia or Northern California. Slightly different experiences and precautions could apply to California, South Africa, Australia, etc.. The substantially larger size of sharks in those areas can make even a passing bite very serious from sheer tissue damage.

FKA Inc.

transcribed by;
Rick Iossi

User avatar
RickI
Very Frequent Poster
Posts: 9117
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2002 1:00 am
Local Beach: SE Florida
Gear: Cabrinha
Brand Affiliation: Cabrinha
Location: Florida
Has thanked: 88 times
Been thanked: 101 times

Re: How to Try to Avoid Negative Shark Encounters

Postby RickI » Fri Oct 31, 2008 10:19 pm

Placement post

User avatar
RickI
Very Frequent Poster
Posts: 9117
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2002 1:00 am
Local Beach: SE Florida
Gear: Cabrinha
Brand Affiliation: Cabrinha
Location: Florida
Has thanked: 88 times
Been thanked: 101 times

Re: How to Try to Avoid Negative Shark Encounters

Postby RickI » Thu Feb 17, 2011 5:02 am

Some additions have been made to the above list. These ideas are intended for consideration in attempting to reduce the odds of negative encounters with sharks while kiting. Sharks can be unpredictable and as such avoidance of problems can't be guaranteed for anyone in the water much less kiters. At the same time, ideally they should reduce the risk of problems. For whatever reasons, the apparent incidence of attacks on kiters has been quite low to date. With prudent actions and luck, hopefully that will continue.

User avatar
RickI
Very Frequent Poster
Posts: 9117
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2002 1:00 am
Local Beach: SE Florida
Gear: Cabrinha
Brand Affiliation: Cabrinha
Location: Florida
Has thanked: 88 times
Been thanked: 101 times

Re: How to Try to Avoid Negative Shark Encounters

Postby RickI » Thu Apr 30, 2015 12:26 pm

An update on this subject from the main forum:
RickI wrote:I'm been recently updating my records of shark attack/incidents involving kiters to pass along requested information to the International Shark Attack File. Still in the middle of it and am not in a position to put out a updated summary but should be able to soon.

As has been the case since the start of our sport, kiter shark attacks/incidents are FAR less common than high wind/thunderstorm related accidents and fatalities. So, use good procedures and common sense to try to avoid negative shark encounters but the far more common threat, at times a fatal one, involves excessive wind gusts/lulls, thunderstorms and the like for kiters.

In general, kiters on plane have had shark incidents far more rarely than kiters in the water. Many sharks could easily overtake and strike kiters at typical planing speed but for whatever reason, fortunately, rarely do so. They have struck boats and kayaks at times, so I wouldn't get too comfortable. There is only one incident that comes to mind in South Africa in the early 2000's potentially involving a mako shark striking a kiters board while planning. There may have been others of course that I haven't heard about.

Most kiter shark incidents and attacks have happened while the kiter has been in the water. This involves common elements with much more frequent bather and surfer attacks. To my knowledge, two kiter fatalities (Stuart, FL, New Caledonia), from shark attack happened or may have been likely to have happened when the kiter was in the water. There may have been a third attack which resulted in a fatality but I am still trying to learn more about that and confirm what may have happened. Sharks may often bite and run. As a generality with all shark attacks, if the bite is in a vulnerable area, the shark is particularly large and/or proper medical care is delayed, death may result from blood loss, trauma and related factors. Most shark attacks are non-fatal as a result involving humans.

There have been more non-fatal shark attacks and incidents involving kiters. Which shouldn't be a surprise considering the amount of time we spend in the water and the large quantity of sharks which may (or may no longer in some cases?), be present. There doesn't seem to be a shortage of sharks in my area for instance perhaps unlike some others. Despite that, kiter attacks and incidents are still rare and less common than wind-related accidents (a few dozen shark bite encounters vs. hundreds of wind injury accidents?). I am still back checking records but there have perhaps been less than two to three dozen shark encounters in which they bit something, the kiter or his board, worldwide, since 1998. The potential for a negative encounter is always there of course, things just don't work out that way for kiters most of the time fortunately. Swimmers, surfers and divers are attacked more commonly than we are.

Some ideas on how to try to avoid negative shark encounters for kiters are discussed at: viewtopic.php?t=2338191&p=688328

If you have heard of other confirmed kiter attacks/fatalities I would like to learn about them, here, or by email to flkitesurfer at hotmail.com or by PM to ricki.

FKA, Inc.

transcribed by:
Rick Iossi.
viewtopic.php?f=1&t=2383777&p=885665#p885665


Return to “FKA, RickI”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 42 guests