Looking at the wind chart and hearing Rick's account, this seems to be a case of gusts taking the wind from the teens to the fifties in a matter of minutes. My old 5th line F One kites did fine at self landing in bursts from 20 up to 35. It would be presumptive to say I know how they would have reacted in this circumstance (but you have to let go of the bar in order for the safety to engage. Only time I ever got dragged was in 30 plus side-on in Sheboygan when I was stupid enough to keep that death grip on the bar).
No, 5th lines aren't perfect and I'm riding a bow (switch 2) that has relatively lousy self landing capacity these days. Rides much better but at the expense of landing. I can see that newer bow control strategies are incorporating 5th line style safety. I wouldn't ride anything as changeable as the conditions in his accident without converting my bar set-up. But I can really identify with the notion that its summer, not much wind, in most circumstances the bow has seemed to have enough depower to handle anything I've gotten into, so I'm not out to second guess the decision to be riding.
Neither am I knocking the no-sympathy votes that essentially are saying that the individual pays the price of their decision. As to comments about knuckle dragging in FL, those might have been a little over the top but don't go to the internet kitchen ( or into extreme sports ) if you can't handle the heat.
I can appreciate that folks are worried that nanny government will come crashing down on kiteboarding, but, despite the widespread images of this accident, there are plenty of positive images of kiteboarding making the rounds. And it is generally universally pleasing to tourist and local observors who don't kite as long as we're polite on the beach and careful with other boaters who are intrigued but don't always get how kites work.
There is footage of people wrapped around phone poles in their cars every night on the news. Particularly gory examples tend to make their way around the country and the internet, and noone is talking about banning cars -- except the global warming set -- but I digress.
More on point, in terms of extreme pursuit, Drudge and others had the link to skydiver who filmed his own freefall in which the chute failed a few weeks back. Now, I don't frequent skydiving forums but I haven't seen a rush of commentary in the popular press about banning skydiving or requiring government inspection of every chute packing. If people are proposing kiteboard bans over this, its because they already had some beef against the sport, so we gotta keep minding our manners but also remember that some folks just don't like seeing other folks having a good time.
Anyway, the TV reporter kept referring to folks being out there parasailing, so we kiteboarders got nothin to worry about, right ...
but seriously, the news account said something to the effect that the local authorities were getting tired of having to deal with this. I think that there may be some modest truth in that but it was part of the news story spin as well. What does government think, what is government doing is an unfortunate hook in virtually every story. For once in its history I'd say the NY times did a decent job of getting the other perspective from folks who practice the sport and that balanced the misfortune of the story.
I can think it is fair for officials to be slightly miffed that folks would get themselves hurt when emergency personnel are on alert for harm from accidental rather than intentional confrontation of the forces of nature. But most kiteboarding accidents don't seem to place responders at risk or require the expenditure of vast sums or unreasonable diversion of resources -- as are required to search and research folks lost climbing mountains in questionable or changeable weather. Rather there is an implicit bargain with society that if you engage in extreme sports, especially at extreme times, that emergency response might be tempered by triage from high demand or concern for risk to responders.
"holes in his knees" - oh bummer man. That must have really hurt although sounds like the body was in shock so it wasn't so unbearable at the moment. MY wet suit took the knee damage in the incident I mentioned above and I wouldn't even want to think about how it might have felt without a wet suit. I think lucky to be alive is the way to look it, but I feel lucky to kiteboard every day I'm out there, so it is not like there is no balance to this risk.
Brian