Depends, I have ridden both and great suggestions by old and broken.
The mako is still smoother than all the shinns and drier. But then again it depends. Are you going to ride on flat water mostly or the ocean? For carving in the ocean the mako for sure. But if you want your board to feel more alive underfoot then the shinn. The concave on the mako can make it for some too smooth, which can equate to dullness for some.
If you want to ride more upright, the mako. The mako allows a more upright surfboard stance.
If you want to leave the water more the shinn.
It all depends.
I run the mako in the surf and a square tipped laluz on the flat ( also a very smooth board which some equate to being a little dull). In my mind no point in having square tips in the ocean and round tips on the flat. I have differentiated and have come to the conclusion that compromise means an average experience in both mediums.
The monk is not for you, asks the rider to ride flat out to get decent feedback from it. Ride it slow and you will wonder why you paid money for it. Ride it hard and fast and you will know why you bought it!
For slower speeds the mako, the red, medium speeds the Dundee.
Depends...