
Author 
Message 
edt

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 10:55 pm 


Very Frequent Poster 

Joined: Fri Jul 16, 2010 6:27 am Posts: 3158 Location: Ford Lake, Michigan

taiguy wrote: UKSurf wrote: Why does a 10m kite have 4x the power of a 5m in your first chart? I would think it would have 2x approx. also the power seems to be increasing with the power of 4 not power of 2 for wind speed. We need Bill Hanson to confirm these figures before they are used to purchase a quiver I haven't seen any information that would corroborate edt's claim. Power increases with respect with the square of the area and cube of the windspeed. But please have Bill come and give us all a short course taiguy think about it for a second, it is ridiculous to go with cubed. If you go with v^3, then if you fly a 12 meter kite in 20 knots, in 30 knots you need a 3.5 meter kite. If you go with v^2, then if you fly a 12 meter kite in 20 knots, in 30 knots you need a 5 meter kite. You can't just look at wikipedia without noting that when they give these figures of v^3 is it not for a kite it is for a turbine. The turbine spins faster the higher the wind. This means it extracts one additional factor of v. If instead of a turbine you are measuring the amount of force pushed back against a car it's 1/2 p v^2 Cd A go look it up, that's because unlike a wind turbine the car doesn't spin around in circles it just sits there in the air. Anyway, just crank out a few numbers and example kite sizes it's pretty easy to see right away v^3 makes absolutely no sense. Also kite size and rider weight scales linearly. Only wind speed scales as square for figuring kite size. So a 20 meter kite pulls twice as hard as a 10 meter kite, and a 200 pound rider needs twice the kite size as a 100 pound rider.


Top 


SSK

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 11:03 pm 


Frequent Poster 
Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2012 2:04 am Posts: 215

the force due to lift = 1/2 * rho * V^2 * Coefficient_Of_Lift * A
Double the area double the force Double the wind speed and square the force.


Top 


SSK

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 11:04 pm 


Frequent Poster 
Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2012 2:04 am Posts: 215


Top 


UKSurf

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 11:10 pm 


Frequent Poster 
Joined: Wed Feb 22, 2012 9:09 pm Posts: 273

taiguy wrote: UKSurf wrote: Why does a 10m kite have 4x the power of a 5m in your first chart? I would think it would have 2x approx. also the power seems to be increasing with the power of 4 not power of 2 for wind speed. We need Bill Hanson to confirm these figures before they are used to purchase a quiver I haven't seen any information that would corroborate edt's claim. Power increases with respect with the square of the area and cube of the windspeed. But please have Bill come and give us all a short course Well I think you can use common sense atleast as far as the area and power goes. look at the first line of your chart. You are saying that a 17m has 11.56x the power of a 5m. So what you are saying is that a 17m kite would have more power than 11 5m kites flown like flexifoil stackers (with at total area of 55m). Did you use this spreadsheet model to work out the low end on the Epic Infinity for Dmitri btw


Top 


taiguy

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 11:14 pm 


Rare Poster 
Joined: Mon Jun 23, 2008 2:13 am Posts: 37

edt wrote: taiguy wrote: UKSurf wrote: Why does a 10m kite have 4x the power of a 5m in your first chart? I would think it would have 2x approx. also the power seems to be increasing with the power of 4 not power of 2 for wind speed. We need Bill Hanson to confirm these figures before they are used to purchase a quiver I haven't seen any information that would corroborate edt's claim. Power increases with respect with the square of the area and cube of the windspeed. But please have Bill come and give us all a short course taiguy think about it for a second, it is ridiculous to go with cubed. If you go with v^3, then if you fly a 12 meter kite in 20 knots, in 30 knots you need a 3.5 meter kite. If you go with v^2, then if you fly a 12 meter kite in 20 knots, in 30 knots you need a 5 meter kite. You can't just look at wikipedia without noting that when they give these figures of v^3 is it not for a kite it is for a turbine. The turbine spins faster the higher the wind. This means it extracts one additional factor of v. If instead of a turbine you are measuring the amount of force pushed back against a car it's 1/2 p v^2 Cd A go look it up, that's because unlike a wind turbine the car doesn't spin around in circles it just sits there in the air. Anyway, just crank out a few numbers and example kite sizes it's pretty easy to see right away v^3 makes absolutely no sense. Also kite size and rider weight scales linearly. Only wind speed scales as square for figuring kite size. So a 20 meter kite pulls twice as hard as a 10 meter kite, and a 200 pound rider needs twice the kite size as a 100 pound rider. Going with a v^3 model, and assuming 12m in 20 knots, an increase to 30 knots puts me on something just slightly smaller than a 7m. Where did you get 3.5m from?


Top 


edt

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 11:26 pm 


Very Frequent Poster 

Joined: Fri Jul 16, 2010 6:27 am Posts: 3158 Location: Ford Lake, Michigan

taiguy wrote: Going with a v^3 model, and assuming 12m in 20 knots, an increase to 30 knots puts me on something just slightly smaller than a 7m. Where did you get 3.5m from?
(20^3/30^3 ) * 12 how'd you do your math? don't see where you can get 7m. (20^x/30^x) * 12 = 7 x log 20  x log 30 + log 12 = log 7, x = (log 7  log 12) / (log20  log30) = 1.33 To get 7 meters you would have to be using force is proportional to v ^ 1.33
Last edited by edt on Fri Dec 20, 2013 11:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.


Top 


taiguy

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 11:28 pm 


Rare Poster 
Joined: Mon Jun 23, 2008 2:13 am Posts: 37

I'm not multiplying by a factor of 12. Square of the area and cube of the speed were things beaten into me back when I started in 08 and I took it for granted then. I recall reading one of Bill's posts about the subject last year and went to go dig it up for you. http://www.kiteforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=2372383&p=751233#p751233He states available power increases with the cube of the velocity as well...


Top 


taiguy

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 11:31 pm 


Rare Poster 
Joined: Mon Jun 23, 2008 2:13 am Posts: 37

I also see you participated in that discussion as well The cubed relationship seems to match my own experience /shrug.


Top 


edt

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Fri Dec 20, 2013 11:35 pm 


Very Frequent Poster 

Joined: Fri Jul 16, 2010 6:27 am Posts: 3158 Location: Ford Lake, Michigan

taiguy wrote: I'm not multiplying by a factor of 12. Square of the area and cube of the speed were things beaten into me back when I started in 08 and I took it for granted then. I recall reading one of Bill's posts about the subject last year and went to go dig it up for you. http://www.kiteforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=2372383&p=751233#p751233He states available power increases with the cube of the velocity as well... ok now when you talk about "power" "force" "energy" all these are precise physical terms with precise mathematical definitions. Power is not "power" power is defined as the amount of energy consumed PER UNIT OF TIME. But we don't feel time! We feel an instantaneous force of the kite pulling us. We don't integrate the force of the kite. Therefore if the "power" is proportional to v^3 then you take the derivative of that which is proportional to v^2. Needless to say it can get confusing because as kiters we don't normally deal with precise units of physics, like impulse, energy, power, force. To a kiter all of those 4 terms, impulse energy power force are all equal, it's how hard the kite pulls you. But they all mean something different. Anyway, in terms of kite size it scales as to v^2 linear with weight linear with kite size


Top 


SSK

Post subject: Re: Power Relative to Windspeed and Kite Size [Reference] Posted: Sat Dec 21, 2013 12:30 am 


Frequent Poster 
Joined: Thu Aug 30, 2012 2:04 am Posts: 215

Even if you are talking power (not sure how you feel power I understand physically measuring a force), it is still linear to the area. There is no squared term for the area. 1/2*rho*A*C*V^3.


Top 



You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum


